Natural ventilation is increasingly being used in buildings. But with openable windows often not possible in cities, designers are turning to our old friend the chimney.
hink chimneys and you're more likely to think Victoriana than high tech. But our old friends can be seen making a comeback on some of the most cutting edge buildings, this time round being used to get rid of hot air not foul smoke.

M&E contractor Drake and Scull has just finished work on a new 12 000 m2 library and learning resource centre for Coventry University. A central tenet of the design strategy for the building, which will provide research and study facilities for over 17 000 students, was the need to be energy efficient and low maintenance. Out goes air conditioning and in comes natural ventilation.

With a noisy site, openable windows for the ventilation are a no-no. Extensive modelling was carried out using computer-based fluid dynamics models to look at alternative strategies. The eventual design solution, led by architect Short & Associates and m&e consulting engineer Environmental Design Partnership, employs a 50-m square plan, with stacks supplying natural light and ventilation, which is also boosted by chimneys around the perimeter. The result is said to be the biggest naturally ventilated building of its type in the world.

The new centre has four floors built around its plan. Under the ground floor is an air supply plenum, and three vertical stacks supply and remove air. Four corner lightwells, seven metres in from the perimeter, supply air to all floors and a single well extracts air from these areas. Twenty stacks are used to ventilate the perimeter.

So how does the system work? Air enters from the supply plenum and travels into the corner lightwells. Here, air is tempered by a heater battery before being supplied into the rooms via low-level dampers. Trench convective heaters warm the air further. High-level dampers exhaust air into the central lightwell or the perimeter stacks.

There are vents in the windows controlled by motorised actuators according to the direction of the wind. The corner lightwells have glazed roofs, also with actuated window vents.

The characteristic chimneys, or perimeter ventilation stacks as the designers like them to be called, are 3-m square and rise to a height 6 m above roof level. With their aluminium terminations, they are not unlike air traffic control towers. They take extract air from dampers on each of the four floors around the square plan, as well as from the basement level.

With an innovative approach to ventilation and building services generally, it is vitally important than on-site relations are good. According to Drake and Scull, handover on the project was 99.9% defect-free and the company's performance drew high praise from Jim Palmer, an associate with the consultants Environmental Design Partnership.

As Drake and Scull's project manager at Coventry University, Nyree O'Conner explains: "Customer requirements rather than cost were the driving factor, with constant communication underpinning day-to-day operations. This ensured the customer's requirements were fully understood and taken into account." Weekly on-site meetings adopted a no-blame approach, cutting down on correspondence and fostering a proactive attitude from the earliest days of the project. Out of this came a rolling programme of work schedules, with clear objectives complementing those of the University and with specific tasks allocated to named individuals.

Programmes were monitored and adjusted to benefit the entire project team rather than specific members, for example the co-ordination of the installation of 300 dampers in the ventilation package. By working closely with the main contractor, Drake and Scull was able to make just-in-time deliveries, reducing on-site storage space requirements and costs.

So far, the University is very pleased with the performance of its new building. Obviously, the acid test comes in the hot summer months, if we have any, when the natural ventilation has to cope with outdoor heat and humidity as well as the heat gains from students and computers.

Well stacked

Coventry University’s new library is not the first building to employ massive stacks to drive ventilation. Architect Short & Associates has teamed up with engineer Max Fordham & Partners on two previous landmarks – De Montfort University’s Queen Building in Leicester and Manchester’s Contact Theatre. The new Contact Theatre opened in 1999, a revamp of part of what used to belong to Manchester University and was originally built in 1963. The building’s nine 30 m stacks, topped with suitably theatrical H-shaped chimney pots, are a dramatic addition to the Manchester skyline. The driving force for the adoption of extract ventilation chimneys was the need to avoid the running costs of air conditioning, from both an energy and maintenance point of view. Here the end result is a fan-assisted passive ventilation strategy, with the fans cutting in at times of peak cooling demand. The designers predict that conditions will rarely necessitate use of the fans – primarily when the wind acts against natural ventilation, ambient temperatures are very high or for night cooling of the structure. The objective is for ten air changes per hour, with a maximum air flow rate of 12 m3/s. Wind tunnel testing by Cardiff University’s Welsh School of Architecture dictated the H-shaped chimney pots. They are said to reduce the risk of downdrafts because they generate a negative pressure whichever way the wind blows. With costs paramount to the theatre, Max Fordham estimates that energy cost savings over a mechanical ventilation and comfort cooling system should be in the region of £4000 per year. De Montfort University’s Queens Building is the granddaddy of naturally ventilated buildings using stack-effect chimneys to drive the ventilation. Finished in 1993, the building provides facilities for 1500 students. The architect’s concept was for a thermally massive structure using a shallow plan and high ceiling heights to make the most of natural ventilation and daylighting. The ground floor classrooms and auditoria are ventilated by the massive chimneys; laboratories and staff areas on the upper floors are served by rooftop ventilators. The natural ventilation strategy is controlled by a building energy management system: motorised dampers open low- level air inlets and the stack exhaust ventilators according to room temperature. The building has been monitored post-occupation and has reportedly maintained satisfactory internal conditions, even during some of the hottest summers on record.