A homelessness charity is resettling 30 rough sleepers a month by extending the temporary winter shelter system into an all-year-round initiative.
For most rough sleepers who have relied on charitable shelters for warmth over Christmas, the New Year would normally herald a return to the cold streets. That was, until three years ago; now, according to charity St Mungo's, 30 rough sleepers are taken off the streets and resettled.

There is a simple reason for this: the "rolling shelter" programme, introduced in 1999 to replace traditional winter shelters.

The benefit of the "rolling shelter" system is that beds are available all year round, rather than just in the cold winter months. These beds are not always in the same place; instead, they "roll" between empty buildings as they become available.

Also, traditional shelters placed no limit on length of stay, and so were usually full by February, whereas rolling shelters limit stay to an average three weeks before move-on accommodation must be found.

The idea of more permanent rolling shelters was part of the government's drive, overseen by the rough sleepers unit, to reduce the numbers of people sleeping rough. While the success of the wider policy has been called into question – the accuracy of headcounts was heavily criticised – rolling shelters are regarded as a vast improvement on the previous system.

Over the past three years, St Mungo's has run a total of 12 shelters in London, opening three at any one time and catering for a maximum of 120 beds. Facilities include rooms with both single and double beds, to cater for both individuals and couples, kitchen facilities, free meals and communal lounges and dining rooms. Shelter staff work with primary healthcare services in assessing rough sleepers' needs and with benefits agency outreach teams so that residents can access benefits more easily and work out claims problems.

Mike McCall, St Mungo's director of operations, explains: "The [old] shelters were run in a very haphazard fashion so people weren't assessed effectively and often the service was misused. Anyone could stay rent-free for four months, so we had people coming in who didn't necessarily need to be there. It was enabling people to continue living unsettled street lifestyles."

In contrast to the comparatively ad-hoc nature of winter shelters, rolling shelters use a more targeted approach. Staff are trained to address the long-term needs of the street homeless and settle them into permanent accommodation. In addition, whereas a number of organisations including Centrepoint, the YMCA and Crisis oversaw the old winter shelters, St Mungo's alone oversees the shelters, so management is more streamlined.

Setting up a shelter is simple in theory, but it can be incredibly time-consuming and locations for new shelters are always subject to residents' say-so. The initial step for St Mungo's is to find empty buildings with conversion potential. Staff send letters to housing associations and local authority planning departments every few months, asking them if they know of any properties. It can take a long time to find somewhere suitable. McCall says: "There simply aren't enough empty buildings out there. We always try and persuade people to let us use somewhere by pointing out that we can improve it through refurbishments and pay the council tax on it. At the end of the day, it's more beneficial in use than if it was idle."

After finding a potential premises, St Mungo's assesses what refurbishment needs to be done. A budget is drawn up for each building and presented to the Homelessness Directorate, which pays for work ranging from a lick of paint to putting in a kitchen or new radiators. If the costs are approved, St Mungo's sets about applying for planning permission from the local authority – another time-consuming process – and consulting local residents and business.

"This can be difficult," McCall admits, "because to many, a shelter next door is not the most attractive option to have as a neighbour. In some cases ,in order to make a shelter work, we have to guarantee that we'll hold coordinated meetings with local businesses, residents and councillors every few months to make sure that there haven't been any problems.

"There have been situations where the neighbours have said no to a planned hostel and we've had to look elsewhere. It's a big obstacle when that happens and usually it's because people are worried about the impact on their neighbourhood and house prices."

The next step is easier – getting enough people into the shelters. Every evening, contact and assessment teams phone to find out how many vacancies there are in the shelters. In some cases there simply won't be enough space for everyone that night, but the teams will try to arrange for them to go in the following day. Working out when people will be moved on from the shelters is fairly simple because of the maximum stay period.

The programme has been criticised for seemingly operating a "conveyor belt" approach to rough sleeping – critics ask, what's to stop a resettled rough sleeper from returning to the streets? Although there is no research on how often this happens, programme directors admit that the shelters are not a miracle cure for rough sleeping. They are, though, says McCall, a step in the right direction.

"If people do turn up again we don't see it as a failure on our part or theirs because we have to help them try to take the next step. Some people can do it first time; others can't. But we try and meet the need that's out there and provide people with options."

The bottom line

Each bed in the cold weather shelter programme between 1999 and 2000 cost £505 a week. The rolling shelter programme has an agreed benchmark of £412 a week for each bed; in fact, each rolling shelter bed costs only £289 a week On average each shelter has three project workers a shift as well as a manager. Staff are employed by St Mungo’s on a mixture of temporary and long-term contracts. The charity is fortunate in that it has a big workforce of more than 550 people, so it can second people from other jobs within the organisation to the shelters. This means staff can expand their skills bases and their careers while the shelters have the benefit of employing people familiar with the charity’s work

The service users

On average, 79% of the people who go to the rolling shelters are male People who have multiple needs (mental health, drug use, help with benefits and so on) make up 79% of residents in the shelters, 51% are people whose primary need is related to drug use More than 50% of those staying at a shelter are successfully resettled after their stay; this figure rises to 65% for those staying more than seven days Rolling shelters have achieved resettlement rates of around 30 people a month since April 2000

At home in holborn

Location:
Southampton Row, Holborn, central London
Beds:
35
Opened:
September 2002
Lease Expires:
2004
Staff:
Total of 15 staff comprising nine project workers, one manager, four night staff and one move-on worker Holborn has a large problem with rough sleepers, mainly because it is very near Covent Garden and the West End. London Underground owns the building, but it was vacant so St Mungo’s approached the company and negotiated a two-year lease. The shelter offers single and double rooms and a large lounge and dining area. To help boost the tenants’ quality of life – and to enourage them to come in – people are allowed to keep pet dogs with them. Also, the charity is working with a local adult education college to boost literacy and numeracy skills among those staying at the shelter.