The area he's talking about is Hillfields, a small knot of housing and industry north-east of Coventry's city centre. In the middle of the 1990s, drug-dealing and the attendant problems of prostitution and crime made Hillfields notorious. Since then, the work of local groups such as WATCH (it stands for Working Actively Towards Changing Hillfields) has reaped rewards, but there are still serious problems with outdated stock, voids, unemployment, antisocial behaviour and the remnants of the prostitution problem.
For a lot of residents, this means housing is the number-one issue in the run-up to the local elections on 10 June. And since there is no party in overall control of Coventry council at the moment, Hillfields could well be an example of how housing can swing an election. "People here don't know how to vote, that's why [the council] is hung," says Shannon. "In this ward most people would vote for the individual, not a party – the person they think will do most for Hillfields."
That's reflected in local people's willingness to support candidates from outside mainstream parties: the city's three Socialist Alternative councillors all represent parts of Hillfields.
The area itself is predominantly a tangle of small Victorian terraces, with a cluster of decaying tower blocks near its heart. Pushed up against Coventry's ring road and bisected by arterial routes and a canal, it feels labyrinthine to drive around.
Equally maze-like are a number of 1980s semi-detached cul-de-sac developments, inward-facing and a source of some grief: they have pedestrian access to other parts of the area through gates to which the residents have keys. Their tendency to leave the alleys locked results in narrow dead-ends that have become haunts for drug users and prostitutes. "We get syringes, used condoms here … it's not nice," says Shannon.
The combination of snarled streets with residential zone traffic-calming measures makes this a difficult area to police, and antisocial behaviour remains an issue. "There's the usual problem with youth," Shannon says. "It's a perceived fear rather than a real fear, though: a gang of teens egg each other on and the old people can get intimidated." To help tackle this, wardens are on patrol while a police crime reduction initiative has paid for two officers to cover the area on bikes, rather than the more customary vans. "People like to see bobbies on the beat," Shannon says.
Community under threat
Yet Hillfields has an energy and vitality that planners try hard – and often fail – to replicate. People congregate in the May sunshine, talking in groups or popping into the dozens of small local shops; it feels lively, even if some shop fronts are boarded up. There's residual industry here, too, in premises often wedged between terraces so tightly it's hard to spot at first glance.
All the same, residents feel this sense of community is threatened. The source of this unease is the "Swanswell project", the council's regeneration proposal for the area, which some feel could obliterate Hillfields or, at the very least, render it unrecognisable.
The Swanswell project aims to tackle some of the main problems faced by central Coventry. Ferociously bombed during the second world war, the city was rebuilt with an inner ring road, a swooping sculpture of over- and under-passes. Now, the city has outgrown that plan and feels throttled by the tangled ring road.
Under the Swanswell project, named after a stretch of the inner ring that would be demolished and rebuilt as an avenue at ground level, the canal and its basin would be expanded to create more open space and the city centre would be free to expand … right into Hillfields. The eight tower blocks at Hillfields' heart, much of which is social housing managed by post-transfer landlord Whitefriars, would be torn down to accommodate this expansion; what would replace them is a source of some controversy.
"They're talking about spending a lot of money and building a 'Champs Elysées' to extend the city centre," Shannon says. "People here say 'that's all very nice but where are we going to live?'."
Meanwhile, there are other pressures on the area's housing. A lot of the small, terraced properties that are the mainstay of its stock have been bought by landlords and divided into flats that accommodate many of the 32,000 students that attend the city's two universities.
There are also several purpose-built halls of residence, with more under construction or proposed. The students aren't popular with locals and posters protesting the expansion schemes are visible on many streets. The problem, says Shannon, is that the students aren't there all year round, which "doesn't make for a cohesive community".
Towering above the halls of residence is the epicentre of yet another controversy, the city's football stadium. It is earmarked for demolition when its replacement in another part of the city is complete next year.
Under a deal between Coventry City FC, the council and private developers, it will be replaced by a residential development, but there has been uncertainty over how much social housing this would include because the club argues the area already has a surfeit of affordable homes. It is certain, though, that the bulk of the new development will be larger, more expensive homes. "We don't want to see a private, gated development," Shannon says. "That wouldn't be good for the area."
It all adds up to a regeneration conundrum as fiddly and perplexing as they get, so it is not surprising that the local elections in this ward, as in many others, will revolve around housing issues.
Hillfields still has its serious problems, but has come a long way; the fear now is that the achievements so far might be seriously threatened by the mega-schemes in the pipeline or that increasing pressure from the centre might irreparably alter the area's unique character and advantages.
"It doesn't need a lot more change," Shannon insists. "Just a little tweak."
How many seats the parties hold in Coventry Council
24, Labour23, Conservative
3, Socialist Alternative
2, Liberal Democrat
2, Independent
Labour: John Mutton, leader of Coventry council (and former Hillfields resident) on …
… housing in Hillfields“One of the problems is lack of diversity in tenure and that’s why unemployment remains high – when people get a better job, they leave. We currently have 25% transience. “I want them to remain in their community as their lives improve and that does mean more diversity in housing. “The Swanswell project will involve moving in mixed-tenure housing as well as some industry. If people are leaving to get jobs, we’ll bring the jobs to them.” … the Swanswell project
“We have regular meetings with local representatives, not just councillors but also residents. Yes, we want to extend the centre; we also want to make it more accessible to residents of Hillfields and the neighbouring district. If eight tower blocks are to be demolished, we will ensure there is replacement housing and we’ve insisted that some of that would be low-rise single flats.” … student housing
“I would rather students be accommodated in specially built buildings than scattered across private accommodation in the city.” … the football stadium
“There will be 25% social housing in the development. It certainly will not be a gated private development, because that would fail. There was a lot of consultation.”
Liberal democrats: Russell Field, councillor, on …
… the demolition programme“In my own constituency of Upper Stoke, [Whitefriars Housing Group] demolished about 300 houses and then replaced them with 300 new ones, but only 25% of them were social housing. If they do that everywhere, we’re going to be left with much less social housing and Coventry currently has a good amount. I want to maintain the current level of social housing.” … the football stadium
“It’s old and right in the middle of a residential area, which can be an inconvenience, so replacing it with housing makes sense. I supported a motion to delay the plan [over fears the council was putting too much money into it] … but I did support it in the end.”
Socialist alternative: David Nellist, Socialist Alternative councillor for St Martins, the ward that contains Hillfields and the city centre …
… housing in Hillfields“Communities are being destroyed. Demolition of good rented housing has taken place with no social alternative being provided. The stuff that’s being built is either student accommodation or luxury housing built as a form of social engineering. Established working-class communities have been torn apart. “At the moment Coventry council wants 25% social housing in all new developments outside the centre. I want that increased to 50% on all developments of more than 10 homes. … student housing
“We’ve put a formal motion to introduce supplementary planning guidance to limit the height of new student accommodation and involve the community in deciding the nature of the new build.”
Conservatives: Brian Kelsey, councillor and shadow cabinet member for regeneration and neighbourhood renewal, on …
… housing in Hillfields“We supported transfer to Whitefriars and we support social housing wholeheartedly if it is in a fair and just manner. Of course we also support homeownership, so that people are able to own their own homes and be in control of their own destinies. “We wouldn’t rush in and change everything in sight. There would be changes, certainly, [but] no one’s going to fall out over this.” … the Swanswell project
“There are serious issues that have to be addressed. It could take 20 years, certainly not five. I’ve never been able to understand why some people want to retain those tower blocks [the eight that are being demolished]. I would think the replacement would include social housing, there would be a mix of housing there and the 25% council social housing guideline would probably be used.” … student housing
“The increase in student accommodation has been a problem for some years now over all sorts of issues: height, parking, all sorts of things.” … the stadium
“We were against the amount of public money going into it. [The old stadium] was sold for housing; it’s too early to say what the exact mix will be.”
Source
Housing Today
No comments yet