With the dust from conference season long since settled, the Conservatives’ promised deregulatory blitz for construction still sticks out in the mind. With the Future Homes Standard set for the bonfire under a Tory government, three industry experts make the case for keeping the new rules - despite their short term cost

shutterstock_4204734635

Source: Shutterstock

Getting application of standard right could solve most viability concerns, says Stace’s Mark Brooks

The Conservative Party’s pledge to scrap the incoming Future Homes Standard (FHS), should they be elected, is framed as a way to improve viability and get more homes built. It is a laudable ambition, but this swingeing approach is over-simplistic and has the potential to increase uncertainty, risk and cost for developers and occupiers.

Through a series of additional requirements under the Building Regulations, the FHS aims to ensure all new residential development is “net-zero-ready” and that new-build homes in England emit at least 75% less carbon than those built to earlier standards. It will come into force in phases over 12 months from 24 March 2027.

Mark Brooks headshot

Mark Brooks, partner at Stace

The argument that the Conservatives have picked up on is that the new rules are too onerous and will make some developments financially unviable. They are correct to a point, but clients, designers and supply chains have planned around the FHS for years. A known standard can be priced and passed back into land value; a reversal adds risk, abortive design and inflated pricing – the very costs it claims to remove.

A known standard can be priced and passed back into land value; a reversal adds risk, abortive design and inflated pricing 

The debate is framed as keeping or scrapping the FHS, regulatory certainty versus a lighter compliance burden, but this is a false choice. 

The real issue is how standards are applied. Getting the application right would resolve most of the viability concerns without lowering the target. The Building Safety Act already scales scrutiny to risk, with higher-risk buildings going through BSR Gateways and other work following a lighter route. The same top-down principle should apply to the FHS, scaling evidence and approval to the building’s type, scale and complexity.

Between full application and deregulation sits a workable position: keep the outcome fixed, accept recognised flexibility where full compliance is not reasonably achievable, and require the justification to be evidenced rather than assumed.

As an industry, we should recognise the recent political posturing for what it is. The drive towards more sustainable building practices is essential and inevitable. Let’s not kick the can down the road in pursuit of notional short-term savings. 

Retain the FHS, apply it proportionately to risk and building type, and focus reform on approval timescales and evidence requirements rather than the target itself.

Mark Brooks is a partner at Stace

Build better now, don’t pay to fix later, says Elmhurst Energy’s Jason Hewins

Shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith has put the FHS back in the spotlight, suggesting a Conservative government would scrap the standard as part of a wider package of deregulation aimed at boosting housebuilding.

Gavin Barwell’s Prosper UK Housing Commission has also piled in, claiming that ditching the FHS could take £10,200 off the bill for every new home.

Stuart Fairlie, Managing Director, Elmhurst Energy (2) (1)

Stuart Fairlie, managing director, Elmhurst Energy

But for Elmhurst, the OpEx side of the equation is just as important as the CapEx. The costs associated with quality of life, health, environmental impact and other longer-term financial commitments linked to housing are just as important as the initial build cost.

The FHS has been long in the making. It was first announced in 2019; since then, we have had years of consultation and interim regulatory changes, including the 30% uplift to Part L in 2022.

We have spent the best part of a decade turning the ship and getting it moving in the direction of the FHS

In an industry not known for moving quickly, we have spent the best part of a decade turning the ship and getting it moving in the direction of the FHS. It has received extensive industry input and technical thinking.

The standard now shows us how building fabric, heating systems, ventilation and renewable technologies can all be designed to work together. Larger housebuilders, specialist developers and some housing associations have already been developing technical designs, successfully delivering and selling homes using FHS-relevant technology like heat pumps and solar panels.

According to Future Homes Hub, at least 20 projects are already building homes using the standard, either through trials or as part of their normal development programmes.

Let’s not make all of that a wasted investment.

With the impacts of climate change and the cost of living already hammering communities across the UK, we need long-term solutions, and not short-term hacks.

With a new home, we have one of the best opportunities to get human health, comfort, climate resilience and energy performance right from day one. Should those opportunities be missed during construction, achieving the same level of performance later can require considerably more intervention, and huge expense. We risk adding a new generation of properties to an existing retrofit challenge that the UK is already struggling to address.

The principle is straightforward: build better now, rather than pay to fix it later.

Jason Hewins is new build dwellings manager at Elmhurst Energy

Temporary stamp duty incentive could temper new standard’s impact on market, says Gusto’s Steff Wright

The FHS absolutely needs to be implemented as planned. Political talk about scrapping it is ill thought through, as the supply chain needs certainty. If manufacturers, installers and developers know the standard is coming, they will invest, build expertise and increase capacity. As that happens, the technologies will improve and costs will come down.

Steff Wright & Jerome Wright

Steff Wright is chairman at Gusto Homes

At Gusto, we have been building homes to a standard that exceeds the FHS for over 30 years. Since 1998, Gusto Homes and Gusto Construction have delivered more than 400 homes to a higher standard than is required by the current regulations. We have learnt from our mistakes and shared those learnings with other construction companies through site visits. The challenge is not whether better homes can be built, it’s how the whole industry gets set up for it.

There will be challenges around quality control for builders using traditional cavity construction, one being airtightness. It is one thing to set a target on a drawing; it is another to be confident you have achieved it before the building is finished. That means getting the details right from the start, making sure your site manager and subcontractors understand what is required, and checking the work at the right stages.

It is cheaper to build these technologies into new homes from the outset and buyers are increasingly asking for homes that cost less to run

The technologies required to build to the new standard - air-source heating, solar panels and batteries - will come at an additional cost. But it is cheaper to build these technologies into new homes from the outset and buyers are increasingly asking for homes that cost less to run. The upfront cost should be seen alongside the benefits they bring to homebuyers.  

In areas of the country where the economics of housebuilding are not viable, other development costs such as the community infrastructure levy should be reduced rather than the quality of the home. The government should also introduce a temporary stamp duty incentive for people buying homes built to the FHS, lasting for the next 18 months. This would give buyers a real reason to choose these homes and give developers a reason to adopt the standard early. It would also help grow the supply chains and practical expertise the industry will need when the standard comes into force.

The only way to drive up standards in housebuilding is through regulatory certainty. The Future Homes Standard is the right direction, so we should get on with implementing it.

Steff Wright is chairman at Gusto Homes