Greenwich park is about to get a strange and beautiful adornment: a weird bronze cone through which the heavens will be made manifest. Thomas Lane found out how it's being made
"This is not a building solution, it's pure engineering," Kevin Martindale says, waving at a shiny, truncated copper-coloured cone that emerges from the ground at Greenwich park. This is the Peter Harrison Planetarium, centrepiece of the National Maritime Museum's Time and Space project. The project team think it might be the most extraordinary project in Europe at the moment, you could certainly make a case for it being the most difficult to construct - hence Martindale's remarks about engineering. And he should know: as Gardiner & Theobald construction manager, he is responsible for erecting it.
The "copper" is in fact phosphor bronze. The cone is clad with sheets up to 12.5 m long, curved and tapered to fit the structure's form. Eighteen sheets will be welded together so that they appear to be one perfect, seamless object. The phosphor bronze sheets are a hefty 8 mm thick yet have been made to a tolerance of ± 0.2 mm. But phosphor bronze is notoriously difficult to weld as it shrinks and distorts with heat, which could make the cone look more like a corrugated iron shed than a perfectly machined artifact. It was so difficult to find a specialist contractor special enough for this that the bronze concept was nearly abandoned. Furthermore, it sits over an inner concrete cone with such bizarre geometry that building it posed a serious challenge.
So why go for such an unbuildable building? According to Diane Haigh, Allies and Morrison's project architect, the legacy of the site demanded nothing less. This is the Greenwich Observatory after all, long associated with the feats of engineering that allowed humans to probe heaven and earth - from telescopes for observing the stars to the Harrison clocks that first helped sailors plot longitude at sea. "We wanted the visible part of the planetarium to have some resonance with the place," she says.
According to Haigh, the geometry of the cone is defined by reference to the celestial equator, the Pole Star and planetary orbits. And because it was to have the appearance of a scientific instrument, it had to have a flawless appearance. "We considered a whole range of cladding materials," says Haigh. "One solution could have been a rendered cone but the eye picks up imperfections. So that's why we went for this precision, engineered solution."
The concrete beneath the cladding is 225 mm thick, which is enough to isolate those within from the world outside. "The sense of wonder and suspension of disbelief when you are in the planetarium would be completely ruined by the noise of people outside - you would be brought down to earth with a bump."
This exacting brief presented the project team with a multitude of challenges. Just physically working on it was tricky because it tilts so steeply: one side is at right angles to the ground and the other is at 55.5°. "If you use a cherry picker on the slanting side you still can't reach out and touch it," says Martindale. It also made setting out extremely difficult because the base was neither a circle nor an ellipse, and the whole site slopes.
The inner cone was made by spraying concrete onto mesh fixed to a steel frame. Getting this in the right place required specialist help. "The geometry meant there was no reference point, so we had a firm of surveyors check at every stage," says Martindale. In theory, if they set out the base accurately, the pre-cut and drilled steelwork would naturally fit together. This theory didn't quite hold up in practice. "When we measured it at the top it was 40 mm out, so we pulled it into position and held it in place."
The concrete could then be sprayed and smoothed flat ready for the bronze. But it took longer than planned. "It took a long time to get the mix right," says Martindale. "And it took a lot longer than we thought to get the setting out and the tolerances right."
Fortunately the project was procured using construction management, and the flexibility this provided meant that battles over delays were avoided (see "Procuring Space and Time", below).
But the concrete was easy compared with the cladding. The basic problem was finding someone to do it. The design team's hopes rested on one firm - Tyne Tubes, who made Antony Gormley's Angel of the North sculpture. The company was hired to give advice, but declined to tender for the actual work. It seemed then that the grand vision was no more than a mirage. Sir John Tiltman, the director of the Space and Time project, says: "The tenders from the other specialists were massively over budget. At that point we seriously questioned whether we could go on with the bronze."
Luckily a firm called Responsive Engineering Group heard about the job from Tyne Tubes and approached the project team. Precision is its specialty: water jet cutting, welding, machining. They make the tooling for airliner wings. They make deep-sea pipelines and the titanium conrods for Formula 1 racing cars. Surely they could build a bronze cone! The project team visited the firm's factory in Gateshead and were thrilled: "Everything was spot on," says Martindale.
The biggest challenge was welding the bronze without warping it. "We've had a lot of experience welding difficult components so we have techniques for countering that," says Peter Bernard, group managing director of Responsive. The welding took place in two stages. First, a series of smaller panels were welded together in the factory to make a big panel, and finally the big panels were welded together on site (see "Making the panels", below).
A neat system has been devised to ensure that the welds that are to be done on site are perfect. Steel bars are fixed near the weld edges. These cleverly make a lifting jig for positioning the panels. Once the panels have been positioned, a device called a turnbuckle is attached between the steel bars to bend the edges of the bronze outwards. "The skill is knowing by how much," says Bernard. "The turnbuckles preset the bronze so when you put the heat on, it returns to its perfect shape."
The welding starts on site next week and will continue for three months. Then the surface will be cleaned and made ready for the finishing touch - treating the bronze in stages to achieve a deep, complex patina.
Finally, sophisticated laser projectors will be installed inside the cone to give visitors the ultimate astronomical experience.
The Time and Space project
The first part of the Time and Space project at The Royal Observatory at Greenwich involved improving the much visited Time Galleries in Flamsteed House to the north of the site, which opened in February this year. The second stage focuses on the southern end of the site, which has been virtually closed off, until now. This involves gutting and refurbishing an observatory called the South Building, and turning it into an education centre. A second existing building, the Altazimuth Pavilion, is being refurbished to provide solar viewing.
The Peter Harrison Planetarium, so called after a £3m donation from an IT entrepreneur, is the only new building on the site. It consists of a reinforced concrete box below ground and the cone that protrudes out of this box above ground. The planetarium will seat 120 people who will be able to view shows on the mysteries of space. The area just outside the cone and the courtyard between the planetarium and the South Building will double up as corporate entertaining space.
Making the panels
The cone is 15.5 m in diameter at the base, and 10 m in diameter at its truncated top, which is fitted with mirrored glass to reflect the heavens. The 18 panels cladding it were made from about 300 smaller ones that were fabricated in a factory. These small panels were cut from large sheets using water jets to a tolerance of ± 0.2 mm. They were then curved to the correct diameter by passing them through conical rollers, and checked for accuracy with laser-cut aluminium templates. The small panels were welded together using a jig and a second set of templates. The finished panels are now being craned into position prior to being finally welded together. The panels are designed to flex as the bronze contracts and expands with the heat of the day.
Procuring Space and Time
The National Maritime Museum persuaded Sir John Tiltman to come out of retirement to look after the Time and Space project. He was previously responsible for looking after the property portfolio of the Royal Household and was keen to go down the construction management route for Time and Space. “In the House I had one or two grim experiences of lump-sum tendering and good experience of management contracting, so I championed the cause when I joined.” These good experiences including the restoration of Windsor Castle after the 1992 fire and the refurbishment of Clarence House in 2002 – Gardiner & Theobald was the construction manager on both of these projects.
Tiltman says the flexibility offered by construction management has been ideal for this project. It enabled work to start once £13m of the original budget of £15m had been raised. “If this had been a lump-sum contract we would have waited for the other £2m before we let the contract. By using construction management we could start work by setting aside the fit-out. The advantage is if you get going on the building it is easier to get the rest of the funding.”
The procurement route has also been ideal for this highly complex project. “I don’t think this would have worked if we had gone down the main contractor route,” says Martindale. Because the bronze has cost more than originally budgeted a main contractor would have tried to
cut corners, and cheapened the whole thing. Furthermore the delays caused by the complexities of building the dome and cladding it would have put a main contractor in an ideal position for a major claim for delay. “I reckon we could have put in a claim for well over a million if this had been a lump-sum contract,” says Martindale. This is the last thing Tiltman wants on his last job. “I wanted to be able to leave without the museum having to face a major claim, he says.
Time and Space - key points
- New planetarium being built as part of £15.5m Time and Space project at Greenwich Observatory
- Architect wants it to look like a precision instrument, so it must look perfect when complete
- Finding a company that was prepared to take on the phosphor bronze cladding was difficult as the material distorts and shrinks when welded
- A specialist precision engineering firm took on the challenge
client and project manager National Maritime Museum
architect Allies & Morrison
construction manager Gardiner & Theobald
structural engineer Cameron Taylor
services engineer Arup
QS Barrie Tankle Partnership
general builder Lancsville Construction
M&E services Inviron
bronze cladding Responsive Engineering
masonry and facade restoration Stonewest
joinery and fit out Edwin Dyson & Sons
window refurbishment TRC Contracts
architectural metalwork OMC Plan Stairways
glazed screens and rooflights EAG
bronze patination Capisco
painting and decorating AG Broadley
sprayed acoustic lining Dave Andrews
fibrous plaster Stevensons of Norwich
lift Doppler Lifts
scaffolding Trad Scaffolding Company
suspended ceilings 4Ceilutions
temporary electrics Wingate
temporary accommodation Wernick Hire
piling Dawson Wam
sprayed concrete Quickseal
tree clearance Connick Tree Care