Opinion – Page 652
-
Comment
The price of perfect justice
Thanks to the Woolf reforms and a recent chancery ruling, parties that win an arbitration on one good point but bring up other issues that have no legal merit may find themselves paying the costs of the loser.
-
Comment
It never rains but it pours
Designers, contractors and authorities that neglect to consider the impact of building near rivers could find themselves liable for flood damage caused downstream. Take care.
-
Comment
Grounds for debate
Unforeseen problems with ground conditions are a major headache and it's crucial to be clear about where the risk lies in the contract. But this is debatable, especially on PFI projects …
-
Comment
Not-so-great court
First person - The British Museum's Great Court opened to critical acclaim, but it's a big let-down, and the reading room is far worse.
-
Comment
Eek a mouse!
Process engineering work falls outside the scope of the Construction Act, so adjudicators would have no jurisdiction in a dispute involving process giant ABB – or would they?
-
Comment
Adjudication on trial
There are strong arguments to support the view that the Human Rights Act does apply to adjudication. If that really is the case, does it mean that the whole process will have to be abandoned?
-
Comment
Reasonable precautions
The government's new facilities management contract is flexible and reasonably fair. However, there are one or two things to beware of before you sign on the dotted line.
-
Comment
Red tape costs lives
First person - This government has done a huge amount for construction, but it needs to realise that bureaucracy does not stop accidents.
-
Comment
Time to admit it
Second opinion - The government seems to be very proud of its anti-cowboy quality mark scheme. Why?
-
Comment
Raising some interest
Late payment has traditionally been a fault of construction's big boys. But new legislation means that smaller firms will have to make sure they pay their bills on time, or else incur the penalty.
-
Comment
Similar, but not the same
If an architect's drawings are used to obtain planning permission for a project and the architect, for whatever reason, then has no further involvement, can the project proceed without infringing its copyright?
-
Comment
Tending towards safety
Despite the CDM regulations, site accidents are on the increase. Beyond CDM, there are several practical steps that can be taken at tender stage to instil a culture of safety on site.
-
Comment
Out of control
Adjudication was set up to provide a quick, effective way to sort disputes. In fact, it's proved all too effective – it's growing at an incredible rate, and turning site relationships into mangled wreckage.
-
Comment
Power corrupts
First person - British construction is thankfully free of corruption, but as more power is put in the hands of fewer people, this may change.
-
Comment
Ask yourself this
How would you feel if an adjudicator decided your case on a question you didn't ask her, without giving you a chance to put your views on it? And do you think a judge would agree with you?
-
Comment
Stand up for their rights
Consultants can fall foul of the Human Rights Act if they are deemed to have contravened one of its provisions while acting for a local authority or other public body. So it makes sense to watch your back.
-
Comment
Getting off the hook
If a designer makes a mistake, when does the obligation to correct it expire? After the relevant bit is built? After practical completion? After the final certificate? Or never …
-
Comment
Europe's grey area
If you get a grant from the state and I don't, surely you'll be at an unfair advantage if we compete for a job. The European Court of Justice was asked to consider this point – with disappointing results.
-
Comment
Box clever
First person - The HBF is doing nothing for housebuilders' tarnished reputations. It needs to let go of the past and start getting radical.
-
Comment
A cold climate
While the introduction of the climate change levy may make Britain look impressive on the world stage, it is unlikely to make the government anything but enemies closer to home.