Your First Home: winners, losers and the price cap problem

burnham healey 2

The government’s new equity loan scheme has been welcomed in principle - but price caps set too low for many local markets, a slow launch timeline and limited overall funding are stoking frustration. Joey Gardiner reports

Sheetal Smith, sales and marketing director at New Forest-based housebuilder Pennyfarthing Homes, was waiting with some anticipation for the launch of the Your First Homes scheme after the idea was trailed by PM Andy Burnham at the Labour Party Conference.

Your First Home (YFH) is Burnham’s reboot of Help to Buy, offering first-time buyers an interest-free equity loan on qualifying new build homes – something for which the industry has been campaigning for years.

Pennyfarthing, which targets sales of 200 private and affordable homes a year, has been an enthusiastic user of previous incentive schemes, such as Starter Homes and First Homes, aimed at first time buyers.

But when the government belatedly announced the local authority maximum prices for homes to qualify for the programme, Smith realised Pennyfarthing will struggle to offer anything without losing money. “My initial thoughts were great - we need that kind of scheme,” she says. “And then when the price caps were announced, to say that I’m disappointed is an understatement.”

Smith is not the only person in the housebuilding industry to be disappointed by the shape and scope of the Your First Home scheme, which initially caused housebuilder shares to spike 13% when Burnham first trailed it. But at the Budget last month chancellor John Healey allocated just £4.7bn to it over five years, and set a series of conditions for usage which appear designed to limit uptake. The Budget watchdog, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) branded the scheme as likely to have only a “marginal impact on housing supply given its limited overall size.”

But nevertheless, there are builders who spy a clear opportunity to benefit, and are optimistic about its longer-term impact. So, what are the problems that are worrying so many in the sector, can they be overcome, and who is set to benefit most?

…

This content is available to REGISTERED users

You are not currently logged in.

LOGIN or REGISTER to access this story

Gated access promo

LOGIN or REGISTER for free access on selected stories and sign up for email alerts.

Take out a print and online or online only subscription and you will get immediate access to:

  • Breaking industry news as it happens
  • Expert analysis and comment from industry leaders
  • Unlimited access to all stories, including premium content
  • Full access to all our online archive

Get access to premium content subscribe today